Skip to the page
Not Just College

For parents of teenagers headed into the trades

AI and the Job Market

My Teen Does Not Want to Go to College

The useful move is not to argue about college, it is to find out whether this is a decision or an avoidance, and those look identical from the outside. A considered no comes with a specific alternative and a first step; an avoidant no comes with a shrug and a subject change. Both are workable, and they need different responses. Almost nothing here is permanent: federal aid is still available years later, and the sequence can be rearranged.

Most parents arrive at this sentence from the same place: a teenager said it at the kitchen table, possibly in a tone, and the rest of the evening did not go well. The worry is not irrational and you do not need to be talked out of it. You need better information and a shorter list of things to say. Start here: “I do not want to go to college” is not one statement, and the versions of it need different responses.

Is this a decision or an avoidance?

A considered no sounds specific. There is a thing they want to do instead, they can name someone who does it, and they have some idea of the first step. An avoidant no sounds like a wall. It arrives with no alternative, it gets vaguer under questioning, and it is often about something else entirely: a subject they are failing, a friend group, a fear of leaving, a fear of being compared to a sibling.

Neither is a crisis. But if you respond to an avoidance with logistics, you will spend six months planning something that was never the point. These questions tend to tell you which one you have. Ask a couple at a time, not as an interrogation.

  • What do you want to be doing in the September after you finish school? Not the career, the week.
  • Who do you know who does that, and have you talked to them about how they got in?
  • What is the first step, and what would it cost to take it?
  • What would need to be true for you to change your mind?
  • Which part of school is the part you actually want to stop doing?

That last one is the highest yield question here, because it does not ask them to defend a position.

If you have already had the argument once

“I am not trying to talk you into anything tonight. I want to understand the plan well enough to be useful. Tell me the first step and I will help with that step.”

Then stop. A first step is a real answer, and no first step is also a real answer.

What if the answer is “I do not know”?

This answer is common and it is not a failure. What it usually means is that they have enough information to reject one path and not enough to choose another.

The productive response is a plan with structure in it rather than an open ended gap. Structure means a date, a paid job, and one or two pieces of research: touring a programme, sitting in on a class, talking to someone who does the work, or applying to something with a real deadline. A year spent working and applying looks nothing like a year spent waiting, and the difference is visible in the calendar.

If they are under eighteen and want to work, the rules about what they can legally do are stricter and stranger than most families expect: start with child labor laws, explained for parents, and if a trade is in play, what age can a teen start an apprenticeship. And if they want to know what the work is like before committing, the honest description of a first year is in what a first year apprentice actually does.

Is this door closing permanently?

No, and this is worth saying to yourself before you say it to them. Federal student aid does not expire. The Pell Grant, which is a grant and not a loan, has a maximum of $7,395 for the 2026-27 award year according to Federal Student Aid, and it will still be there if they want it at twenty two.

One rule is worth knowing now, because families get it wrong in both directions. Being seventeen does not stop a student getting federal aid, and moving out does not make them independent. For the 2026-27 award year a student is independent only if one of eight specific conditions applies. The first is having been born before January 1, 2003. The other seven include marriage, graduate study, military service, having dependents and court-determined guardianship, per the Federal Student Aid Handbook. Otherwise they are dependent and a parent is a required contributor on the FAFSA. That threshold is a birth date and it moves forward every award year.

Short programmes are newly in scope for federal grant money too. Workforce Pell became available to students on July 1, 2026, for programmes of at least 8 weeks and less than 15 weeks of instruction and between 150 and 599 clock hours. Both windows apply at once, which rules out a lot of what is advertised. See Workforce Pell, explained.

What should I check before saying yes to an alternative?

If the alternative is a registered apprenticeship, ask to see two documents. 29 CFR 29.5 requires a programme’s written standards to contain an outline of the work processes the apprentice will be trained in, and a progressively increasing schedule of wages. Asking for those two is a sharper question than “is this a good programme,” and the answer arrives on paper.

Ask about completion too. The most recent national completion rate DOL published in a citable document was 46 percent, for fiscal year 2014, with a cancellation rate of 41 percent, in ETA Bulletin 2015-10. That figure is old, and DOL treats low completion as a reason for technical assistance rather than scandal. It is still worth asking a specific programme for its own number.

If the alternative is a private training school, ask what percentage of students complete, how many graduates find work in the field, and to see the contract first. If the school will not hand over documents before you commit, the FTC’s advice is not to enrol. Do not lean on the federal cohort default rate to compare schools right now: it reads near zero almost everywhere because of the pandemic payment pause, so it cannot distinguish anything.

On the money, be careful with headline figures, including the government’s own. DOL advertises an average post-completion salary somewhere between $84,000 and $86,000 depending on which of its own pages you read, neither figure carries a year, and the higher one is footnoted to a single state’s reporting system. The dated, surveyed, national numbers are the BLS medians: electricians had a median wage of $62,350 in May 2024, with about 81,000 openings a year projected for 2024 to 2034.

What this looks like in practice

Delia’s son told her in March that he was not going, and her first three attempts to discuss it ended within a minute. On the fourth she asked only the last question on the list above: which part of school do you want to stop doing.

The answer was all of it, but specifically the part where he sits still. That is information, and it moved the conversation off the word college, which is where it had been stuck.

What they did next was small. He kept his weekend job, they toured one programme in April and one in June, and he applied to an apprenticeship intake with a real deadline, mostly to find out what applying involved. He was not accepted that cycle, applied again the following year, and started. The details are illustrative rather than a template. The part worth copying is the sequence: one honest question, then a calendar, then an application.

Where to go next on this site

If the worry is money, training cost comparison puts the routes side by side and apprenticeship, trade school or community college explains what each one is.

If the worry is that the trades are a dead end or already crowded, are the trades getting oversaturated answers it with federal projections, and which jobs are actually safe from AI covers the technology version of the same fear. If the worry is their body, do the trades wreck your body has the injury data without the reassurance. And if the teenager in question does want a degree, in computing specifically, that conversation is at should my teen still study computer science.

This site does not know your child and will not tell you whether to hold the line or let go. What it can say is that this goes better when the argument is about a specific plan rather than about a category, and the questions above are the fastest route to one.

Questions parents keep asking

Should I insist on at least applying, as a backup?

That is a family decision and this page will not make it for you. What is worth knowing is that an application is not the only thing that keeps the door open. Federal student aid does not expire, community colleges take applicants year round, and a teenager who works for two years and then enrols is a common story rather than a cautionary one.

Will they still be able to get financial aid later?

Yes. Nothing about turning down college at eighteen removes eligibility. One rule does surprise families: for the 2026-27 award year a student counts as independent only if one of eight specific conditions applies, the first of which is having been born before January 1, 2003. Moving out is not among them, so a parent will usually still be a required contributor on the FAFSA.

What if they want a trade but cannot get into an apprenticeship this year?

That is common and it is not a verdict. Programmes run intakes on their own cycles and competition varies enormously by local and by year. In the meantime the useful things are paid work, any relevant coursework, and the application itself, which is covered in how to apply for an electrical apprenticeship.

How do I tell whether a training programme is legitimate?

Start with the FTC’s sharpest test: if the school will not give you the documents to review before you commit, do not enrol. Then check completion and placement figures at TrainingProviderResults.gov. More checks are in how to spot a trade school that is selling you.

Is it true that half of apprentices do not finish?

Roughly, and DOL publishes it. The most recent national completion rate published in a citable DOL document was 46 percent, for fiscal year 2014, with a cancellation rate of 41 percent. It is an old figure and it is the one DOL has made quotable. Ask any specific programme for its own completion rate.

The long version, for the teenager

Career Planning for Teens

Thirty-five short chapters that walk a teenager from narrowing down a trade to getting accepted onto an apprenticeship and reaching a first wage without borrowing against it. Written to be read alone, at around age 13 to 17.

Jenna Hale writes this site and wrote that book, so read this as the author pointing at her own work. Nothing here is held back for it: the page is the whole answer, the book is the same ground at a teenager's pace.

Read the listing on Amazon

Written by Jenna Hale. Last checked against the sources on .